Evaluation of suction measurement by the tensiometer and the axis translation technique

Abstract

The axis translation technique is a well-established method for imposing values of suction in unsaturated soil samples. High-suction tensiometers are more recently developed devices used for measuring pore water pressures in soils, including negative pore water pressures (i.e. suctions) below absolute zero. Both these techniques are comparable in terms of the suction range in which they operate. In this work a tensiometer has been used to measure suction values imposed by the axis translation technique in kaolin samples inside a pressure plate and a triaxial cell. The tensiometer has been kept in contact with the soil sample to track pore water pressure variations throughout the duration of the tests. The suctions measured by the tensiometer have been compared to those imposed by the axis translation technique and it was found that the suction measured by the tensiometer was always smaller than that imposed. Two scenarios are proposed to explain this. The first scenario considers the presence of water inside and below the high air entry value ceramic plate whereas the second one hypothesises the lack of equilibrium in terms of soil water content when suction is measured. The latter scenario seems to be supported by the evidence in the literature of equilibration times for pressure plate tests that are significantly longer than those reported for the present testing programme. Implications of both scenarios for laboratory testing are discussed. © 2008 Taylor & Francis Group, London.