Self-help cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia : a systematic review and a randomized controlled trial

Abstract

Insomnia is recognized as one of the most common sleep complaints accompanied by daytime consequences in the general population worldwide. In recent years, the use of self-help cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) has become a popular treatment option for insomnia.

Firstly, a systematic review was conducted as an update and extension of a previous review (van Straten & Cuijpers, 2009). Two researchers systematically searched 6 major electronic databases in June 2012. We independently selected relevant publications, extracted data, and evaluated methodological quality according to the Cochrane criteria. Meta-analyses of self-help CBT vs. waiting-list (WL), routine care or no treatment, therapist-administered CBT, and placebo were performed. Twenty randomized controlled trials were included; 10 of which were recent publications. Results showed that self-help CBT improved sleep, sleep-related cognitions, and anxiety and depressive symptoms. Effect sizes for sleep diary-derived sleep efficiency (SE), sleep onset latency (SOL), and wake after sleep onset (WASO) at immediate posttreatment were 0.80, 0.66, and 0.55, respectively. The average attrition rate of self-help CBT at immediate posttreatment was 15.6%. Therapist-administered CBT was significantly more effective than self-help CBT. Subgroup analyses supported the inclusion of telephone consultation, but not “full” multi-component CBT and programs  6 weeks. In conclusion, self-help CBT is efficacious and acceptable as an entry level of a stepped-care model for insomnia. In places where face-to-face treatments are unavailable or too costly, self-help CBT can be considered as an adequate compromise. Secondly, a randomized controlled trial was conducted to evaluate the efficacy of an Internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) in Chinese insomnia population with or without medical and psychiatric comorbidities. Three hundred and twelve eligible participants were randomized to self-help CBT with telephone support (SHS), self-help CBT without telephone support (SH), and WL groups in a ratio of 1:1:1. Participants in the SHS and SH groups received self-help treatment once per week for 6 consecutive weeks, whereas participants in the WL group began treatment after 12 weeks of assessment. In addition to the standard self-help treatment, the participants in the SHS group received weekly brief therapist-administered telephone support. The Internet-based CBT-I showed significant improvements in insomnia symptoms and sleep-related dysfunctional cognitions. Improvement was further enhanced by weekly brief telephone support. The results suggested that Internet-based CBT-I is effective and acceptable to treat insomnia.