Detection of human papillomavirus in cervical carcinoma: Comparison of peroxidase, Nanogold, and catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD)-Nanogold in situ hybridization

Abstract

We compared three in situ hybridization (ISH) methods for their applicability and sensitivity in detecting human papillomavirus (HPV) in 61 cases (1 Grade 1, 18 Grade 2, 42 Grade 3) of routinely processed squamous cell cervical carcinoma. A commercially available biotinylated probe for HPV- 16/18 was applied to serial sections and detected by conventional streptavidin-biotin-peroxidase ISH, streptavidin-Nanogold-silver ISH, and catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD)-Nanogold-gold ISH. The latter method involved signal amplification by peroxidase-catalyzed deposition of biotinylated tyramides at the hybridization sites, followed by detection of accumulated biotin by streptavidin-Nanogold made visible by autometallography. The HPV-16/18 detection rates for the three methods were 39.3, 44.3, and 65.6%, respectively. In all of the three ISH methods, a punctate staining pattern (single or multiple intranuclear spots of variable size), presumably indicating viral integration, was highly predominant among the positive cases. Two of the cases identified as positive by streptavidin- biotin-peroxidase ISH were rated negative with streptavidin-Nanogold-silver ISH, whereas six cases that were clearly negative with streptavidin-biotin- peroxidase ISH became positively stained with streptavidin-Nanogold ISH. All of these discordant cases were positive by the highly sensitive CARD Nanogold-gold ISH. In addition, the high detection sensitivity of CARD- Nanogold-gold ISH was confirmed by its ability to detect single copies of HPV-16 in SiHa cells. In general, we found that the intense black reaction product from Nanogold autometallography gave superior contrast to that obtained with the peroxidase system. After tyramide signal amplification, the staining was so clearly visible that preparations could be readily screened under low magnification. Our findings precisely demonstrated the need for improved sensitivity in the in situ detection of HPV. The CARD-Nanogold-gold technology looks promising as a highly sensitive method for routine ISH in molecular pathology.